chef moz restaurant guide part of the open directory project
new search | email chefmoz | add restaurant | become an editor |

AMERICAN

J. Arthur's Restaurant


2843 Soco Road - map
Maggie Valley, NC 28751
828.926.1817
828.926.0019 fax

Hours
5 PM - 10 PM Wed- Sat

add / change info

Price (dinner)$$
Price (lunch)$$

Food***
Service****
Ambiance****.5
Overall***



Features
kids' menu
takeout
private room
private parties
phone ahead seating
offsite catering
kid friendly
large groups ok
fireplace
outdoor/patio dining
nice view


Accepts
cash
bank debit cards
American Express
checks

Smoking
section

Dress
formal


Alcohol
full bar
wine list
extensive wine list


Parking
own parking lot


Handicapped Access
completely accessible
large print menu

Top: United States: NC: Maggie Valley



Reviews



review it    add a link


Show 10 |  20 |  30 |  50  reviews on each page

Expensive but worth the money
I've eaten there on a few occasions. The restaurant is very classy, quiet, ritzy looking and elegant, lit mostly by candlelight, great for a romantic dinner. All I've ever eaten was the steak, which was cooked exact to order. The waiters and waitresses are attentive, without bothering you. They take care of you, but don't spend the whole time hounding you. Everything was prepared perfectly and all in all it's worth every penny spent.    [05 Feb 2000 23:50:35]

Food: ****   Service: ****   Ambiance: *****   Overall: *****
Recommended Dishes: Steak and desserts

     ­czarria   



Quite Good!
Consistently well-prepared dinners. While known for their prime rib, I am a fan of the salmon. Also, don't let the extra dollar deter you: order the gorgonzola salad dressing. Delicious. The service is great, and the setting perfect for this little mountain town.    [24 Jan 2002 16:49:26]

Food: ***   Service: *****   Ambiance: *****   Overall: ***

     ­Sandee Wright, Innkeeper   info at TimberwolfCreek dot com



Hot Waitress
I went with my wife and we had this beautiful waitress named KD who was a teacher at Pisgah, she was very helpful. She got a nice tip from me.    [24 Jun 2005 18:54:13]

Food: ****   Service: *****   Ambiance: *****   Overall: *****
Recommended Dishes: KD

     ­SK   



Not as good
We have eaten at Manero's restaurant for years when Art Ternan owned it, the food was much better then J.R's ever could hope to be. A big disappointment including the management - they were not trained by their grandfather.    [03 May 2003 11:33:52]

Food: *   Service: **   Ambiance: ***   Overall: *
Recommended Dishes: Pizza across the street.

     ­Roni Setti   



A Great Family
I had the honor to work for this family for a year and I will say that I would work for them again if I was still in NC. Rick dedicates his life to that building and upholds the highest quality of service, food, drinks, and expects that of his employees. 1 bad review is tiny compared to the huge numbers of dinners his does in 1 night, everynight.    [03 Dec 2003 14:13:33]

Food: ****   Service: *****   Ambiance: *****   Overall: ****
Recommended Dishes: Famous for their salads

     ­Leah Vass   



Good meal
We ate dinner there September 2005 and had really excellent prime rib.

My husband enjoyed the key lime pie. I had strawberry shortcake which was kind of odd -- vanilla ice cream and apparently frozen berries plus whipped cream on top of a piece of pound cake (?). Quite palatable, though.

Service was good.    [24 Sep 2005 17:42:08]

Food: ****   Service: *****   Ambiance: ***   Overall: ***
Recommended Dishes: prime rib

     ­HA   



Disappointed
My husband and I have been dined twice on vacation and have not been pleased. The service is from the staff is great but the meals were not top of the line nor comparable to the price they charge. We expected a little more quality for our money as we intended on fine dining. We tried it twice to make sure it was just not a fluke the first time that we were not satisfied.

The atmosphere is wonderful. Beautiful building, nice and cozy as something you would expect in the Mountains.    [10 Aug 2006 08:35:40]

Food: *   Service: ****   Ambiance: ****   Overall: *

     ­Fayetteville NC   



Too Pricey * Mediocre Food
My wife & I stopped in yesterday as it appeared to be the only restaurant that saw in the area that looked professionally run. The building is beautifully done in a country-like (Cracker Barrel-like) setting with a big front porch with rocking chairs.
The inside has two floors, filled with country-style wooden chairs & tables. Very nice atmosphere.

You can expect $45-$50 for a party of two without appetizer, cocktails, or alcoholic beverage.

The atmosphere was good with the exception of being a bit noisy. Where we were sitting, we had difficulty hearing each other. Our table was between two other tables holding larger groups of noisy people. This could have been just a coincidence but it WAS rather annoying.

Our waitress was a bit on the chatty side. On more than one occasion during our meal we could not get her attention when needed as she was carrying on lengthy conversations with the large group seated to out side. I'm not sure, but it actually seemed as if she were friends with the party.

The service was rather slow as it seemed there was not enough wait staff. I will say that this could have been caused by the two larger parties that our server was handling. 25 minutes between ordering and getting our salads. Another 25 till the entrees arrive.

The menu actually has nothing special. No real signature dishes other than their "Gorgonzola Salad". I will say that the salad was delicious made with spring greens as well as iceberg lettuce topped with their Italian dressing containing the namesake cheese sprinkled throughout. The Prime Rib was good, but nothing special for the price of $20.95 for an 8 oz. slice. My wife had the Fish & Chips ($12.95) which consisted of a couple Fish Sticks/Patties served with Steak Fries.

They DO have a kid's menu for only $7.95 per child.

All-in-All: Decent food, Clean, Good Atmosphere, a little slow on service, & Pricey.    [25 Jun 2007 14:46:27]

Food: **   Service: ***   Ambiance: ****   Overall: **
Recommended Dishes: Gorganzola Salad (Italian Dressing with Gorganzola cheese added)

     ­Chris, Lincolnton, NC   


  --------------------------

Review J. Arthur's Restaurant in United_States/NC/Maggie_Valley
Headline
Review*   Don't know what to write?

Recommended Dishes
Ratings

Overall*
Food
Service
Ambiance
Reviewer Information
show my name (or nickname) with my review
Name 
show my e-mail address with my review
E-mail 
    Please provide a working email address so we can reach you if something in your review isn't clear. Reviews submitted without e-mail addresses will usually not be accepted. Your email will not be used for any other purpose (unless you ask that it be shown with your review - then we'll show it with your review, too). We will never send you unsolicited email, or sell your name to anyone, under any circumstances.
show my organization (or hometown) with my review
Organization 


Please note: this form does not send a message to the restaurant, it submits a review to the ChefMoz dining guide.

* required field


This area needs an editor.

Copyright © 1999-2003 Netscape. - Last updated 25 Jun 2007 20:59:37 EDT - edit