chef moz restaurant guide part of the open directory project
new search | email chefmoz | add restaurant | become an editor |

ITALIAN

Butch's Italian Cafe
4720 E. Main St. - map
Whitehall, OH 43213
614.864.7300

Hours
Mon.-Thurs. 11:30AM-2:30PM 4PM-9:30PM
Fri.-Sat. 11:30AM-2:30PM 4PM-10:30PM
Sun. Closed

Web Information
web page    menu

add / change info

Price (dinner)$$
Price (lunch)$

Food*****
Service****
Ambiance***.5
Overall*****



Features
kids' menu
takeout
offsite catering


Accepts
cash
American Express
Visa
Diners' Club
MasterCard/Eurocard
Discover
Carte Blanche

Smoking
not permitted

Dress
casual


Alcohol
full bar

Reservations
accepted


Parking
public transit accessible
own parking lot


Handicapped Access
completely accessible

Top: United States: OH: Whitehall

Description



Butch's Italian Cafe

Serving Italian cuisine in the heart of Whitehall, east of Hamilton Rd. on E. Main St. This restaurant was acclaimed in a past Grumpy Gourmet article. The official history of the restaurant:
Butch's Italian Cafe is owned and operated by Butch Zurbriggen. Butch has owned the restaurant for 8 years, but his roots here stretch much further. Butch began working in this very building in 1969, when it was Joseppi's restaurant, and he was only 13 years old.

He mowed the grass and cleaned up. Soon Butch got a job as busboy and later he moved up to dishwasher. In these early years the restaurant took on a name change. You may remember it as Armando's. Butch continued to work at the restaurant through his teen years and into his early twenties where he eventually learned the find art of good Italian cooking from his mentor, and then owner, Tom Moretti. When Mr. Moretti decided to sell, Butch got the opportunity to continue its success, and has done just that for 32 years. That's a lot of "on the job" experience. Butch now operates a newer restaurant of the same name in Canal Winchester. Not sure of the status of the ownership of this location, however an C.W. article seem to indicate he had sold his interest in the Whitehall location which may be renamed at some point. No matter, as they have continued the tradition of fine Italian dining.

The restaurant is known for it's "build your own pasta dish" selection of ingredients and styles. Specialty dishes include Parmesan chicken, various pasta dishes, pizza and many other choices. This is an upscale Italian restaurant.

Closed: Sundays, Thanksgiving, New Year's Day, Memorial Day, Labor Day, Christmas Day.

Catering info at:
http://www.butchsitaliancafe.com/catering.html






Reviews

review it    add a link
At Butch's Italian Cafe, you can build your own pasta. - CitySearch, Libby - suggest change
Columbus' relationship with Italian food: That's amore - The Columbus Dispatch, Doral Chenoweth aka Grumpy Gourmet, 22 September 2000; .... This restaurant introduced the SAR (some-assembly-required) plan for building your own pasta dish with a selection of ingredients and styles. The patron favorite: chicken Parmesan dusted with seasoned flour and crumbs, grilled, served with marinara sauce and topped with mozzarella and mushrooms ...... - suggest change
Selected Top Ten Italian Restaurant - The Columbus Dispatch - awards for the past 7 years. - The Columbus Dispatch, The Grumpy Gourmet; "I've long found this restaurant to fill my needs when I need big food. I go there hungry. Best, Butch's is about nourishment and in this case, nourishment is supported with quality and a well-chosen wine list sold at state minimums plus $3 corkage. I can live with that." - suggest change




Show 10 |  20 |  30 |  50  reviews on each page

GREAT FOOD
GREAT ITALIAN FOOD. BEST CHICKEN PARMIGIANA IN COLUMBUS    [18 Jan 2003 10:30:02]

Food: *****   Service: ****   Ambiance: ****   Overall: *****

     ­JAMES   



Great Food!
Great Italian food. Best Chicken Parmigiana in Columbus.    [14 May 2004 08:31:49]

Food: *****   Service: ****   Ambiance: ****   Overall: *****
Recommended Dishes: Chicken Parmigiana

     ­James   



Still Great
I've been eating good Italian food in this building for over 30 years...First it was Joseppi's...then Armando's...and for quite awhile now Butch's.

I am one of those who has never found a place that can make better Italian food then I can cook myself at home...but, this place comes close.

The only complaint is that it is small...there is a good chance you will be seated with the back of your chair against someone else...going to the restroom on a crowed Friday night can sometimes be an adventure...I suppose for the regulars would call it intimate...I call it crowded.

If you want atmosphere, go to Buca or Spaghetti Warehouse...If you want cheap, go to Olive Garden...If you want great Italian food, go to Butch's.    [24 Oct 2006 16:59:41]

Food: *****   Service: ****   Ambiance: ***   Overall: *****
Recommended Dishes: Have yet to find something I dislike.

     ­ohioscott   


  --------------------------

Review Butch's Italian Cafe in United_States/OH/Whitehall
Headline
Review*   Don't know what to write?

Recommended Dishes
Ratings

Overall*
Food
Service
Ambiance
Reviewer Information
show my name (or nickname) with my review
Name 
show my e-mail address with my review
E-mail 
    Please provide a working email address so we can reach you if something in your review isn't clear. Reviews submitted without e-mail addresses will usually not be accepted. Your email will not be used for any other purpose (unless you ask that it be shown with your review - then we'll show it with your review, too). We will never send you unsolicited email, or sell your name to anyone, under any circumstances.
show my organization (or hometown) with my review
Organization 


Please note: this form does not send a message to the restaurant, it submits a review to the ChefMoz dining guide.

* required field


Editors: ctoys

Copyright © 1999-2003 Netscape. - Last updated 27 Oct 2006 19:15:40 EDT - edit